Caked Co. Lip Fondant Review + Swatches

This post contains affiliate links. Please read the disclosure + thank you for supporting Simply Amanda!

Caked Co Lip Fondants

I recently got the chance to try out Caked Co. Lip Fondant lipsticks in three shades. I was able to snag them through an Ipsy Offer! This is the first Ipsy Offer I have ever redeemed and it was such a good deal. I got 3 liquid lipsticks for $18 (a $48 value!) It was too good of an opportunity for me to pass up. I snagged the Sweet Talker Set which is three shades — Creme de la Creme, Low Key and Legit.

So here’s a little bit about Caked themselves —

We don’t test on animals, only boys.

We’re an indie, street art inspired makeup company that packs everything sweet into one. Our goal at Caked Makeup is to serve you on-trend, wearable & fun beauty products (and accessories!) that will make you feel some type of way.

Our unique mousse-to-matte Lip Fondants are not only delicious, but last all day without any touch-ups. It’s true l♥ve!

Located in Tampa, Caked Makeup is run by 2 sisters & launched on the sweetest day of the year– Valentine’s Day, 2016. We can’t get enough of the glamorous and ever-evolving makeup world, and hope you love everything we dream up for you.

I was dying to try Caked for such a long time, but never got the chance to. Their sweets-themed cosmetics are so cute and I love the name “lip fondant.” I was really excited about this offer because I loved indie, cruelty-free cosmetics brands. Plus they’re located in Florida (like me!)

The Packaging

Caked Co Lip Fondant

I cannot get over how adorable this packaging it. Is it not the cutest thing you’ve ever seen?! They have a bright pink top that looks like frosting and sprinkles on a cupcake! The top of the lid has a C that looks like a donut with a bite in it and the box is pink and purple with frosting and sprinkles on it too with their logo. That alone totally caught my eye about these lippies.

The lipstick tubes feel heavy duty and full of product — unlike some other liquid lipstick brands. It doesn’t feel lightweight or cheap at all. Definitely worth the price!

Related post:  April 2017 Ipsy Glam Bag Review


Now here are the lip fondant swatches!

Caked Co Lip Fondant Swatches

The colors are absolutely gorgeous and I love each one. Here’s a little bit about each shade:

  • Creme de la Creme is a really beautiful cool-toned nude. On fairer skin tones, it may come off as a little bit more of a brown color.
  • Low Key is a dusty, muted terracotta. According to their website, this shade either pulls red or pink depending on your natural lip color. I personally found this color to look like a more reddish tone rather than pink on me (as pictured above.) But it is somehow very distinctly different from your average red lipstick.
  • Legit is a deep berry color with blue undertones. It’s like a purple/hot pink shade without being TOO on the purple side.

My favorite out of all three is definitely Low Key!

The Formula

Caked Co Lip Fondant

The formula of these liquid lipsticks is AMAZING. They smell like heaven and they are so long lasting. Each one has a vanilla scent that is not overpowering and they do not come off easily or flake. It is so creamy, applies easily, and is super comfortable. I wore each color out for several hours and each one was extremely transferproof and kissproof. This formula dries down to matte super quick and looks gorgeous when it dries.

The lip fondants don’t accentuate fine lines when they dry and they do not budge. Even though they dry quickly, I did not find the actual formula to feel drying on my lips like some other matte liquid lipsticks can be. The formula is mousse-like and reminds me of OFRA liquid lipsticks. I always prefer a mousse-like texture for my liquid lipsticks because they feel so smooth on the lips.

Overall, I loved each lip fondant so much. I am so glad I was able to try them out through an Ipsy Offer and I cannot wait to buy more. The packaging and colors wowed me, but the formula sealed the deal! I highly recommend these lipsticks because they are so high quality and affordable. Caked offers free ground shipping on domestic orders over $35 and they ship internationally.

Have you tried Caked’s Lip Fondants before?

Caked Co Lip Fondant



  1. April 2017 / 6:52 am

    I hadn’t heard of this brand before. I adore the packaging it is so pretty and sweet. I hope they ship to australia

    • Amanda
      April 2017 / 6:18 pm

      Yes! They ship internationally 🙂

  2. April 2017 / 1:31 pm

    The packaging is adorable and I really like the 3 colors you have here! beautiful!

  3. April 2017 / 3:43 pm

    I love this!!! Your post made me really consider trying these fondants!!! I’m subscribing!! 👍🏾

  4. April 2017 / 9:02 am

    I am so going to purchase these. Love all the colours and your swatches but low key is definitely speaking to me. Great review!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *